It's all good, it is okay to both approve and want to eat him. Now it's not advisable to do either, but it's okay to do so. Both will result in a mightily upset stomach though. Just fair warning. The sharks in the waters around the island can tell you more about that. Or they could, if you spoke big shark thoughts.

"Aren't sharks the wolves of the sea?"

Fair point. Perhaps it's like a different accent. Maybe Saxsice has a drawling 'Murican accent, and the sharks are like fancy French accents, but not real ones, more like the ones the actors imitate in the movies so people know that the characters are speaking in French even though they're speaking English.

"Hey, I think I smell Axe body spray...the teen has to be that way..." He points from the back of his headless mantis, then as it wobbles he goes "whooooa!!!" and jumps to the back of another one.